Opening Thoughts:
Paul is writing to Timothy to give direction for him about
how to lead a congregation. It makes sense then, that he would give instructions
on the way we should worship. He starts by defining the heart of the attitude that
people should have.
It is probably interesting to us that he so intertwines the
actions of the people and the attitude of their hearts. Consider what special
things that we do to make our worship special.
Go ahead and list some of the things in the comments.
Reflect on the outward actions and traditions that we have to outwardly put
into practice the attitudes that God would ask us to have.
Digging In:
He starts off by saying that there is ONE God. There is only
one mediator; one person by which we can talk to God, as well as be accepted by
him. Let’s praise that person—Jesus Christ! And he says everyone should be
prayed for. This might seem obvious. But it is important when we think about
the purpose of the church to think of the two parts, God and Everyone, that are
being connected. Too often we think of ourselves, or our family, or our
friends.
Then, there are directions specifically for men and women. “But
I want men everywhere to raise up holy hands in prayer.” This word does mean men, and it should be
contrasted with the directions for women. Men are being told that though they
find themselves easily angered, or fall into arguments with others, that this
is not the way of God’s people. At the heart of God’s people is lifting up holy
hands. The men are penitent, and humble.
They have repented of their faults and they are wearing Christ’s righteousness,
as they pray together for everyone.
Then for women, he describes the importance of inner beauty
that shows up in Christian actions, and reminds them that it is important to
dress modestly and avoid putting too much importance on the outward appearance.
Focus on “the unfading beauty of a gentle and quiet spirit,”(1
Peter 3:4) as opposed to the self-obsessed, vain spirit shouting “Look at me!”
Then he reminds Timothy that it is the role of a man to lead
and have authority in Christian teaching, and that it is not the place for a
woman to do that.
When Paul brings up what happened in the garden, he is
reminding them that in the garden, during the fall, both Adam and Eve failed to
fulfill their role. Eve stepped out of her role as helper, and Adam did not do
his job as head. It sounds like in these
verses that Eve is responsible because she was the one who was deceived. But we
know that Adam, as the head, is held responsible for both of their acts. (Romans
5:12) “Sin entered the world through one man, and death through sin.”
If you are troubled by the wording of verse 15, know that there
are people who have had a great deal of difficulty fitting the phase “women
will be saved by childbearing” together with the rest of Scripture. The word
saved is sometimes translated: restored, cured, made whole…. You could argue
that he means that women are restored to their role in God’s creation when they
do the important and difficult job of being a mother, if they continue in
faith, love , and holiness as they do so. What it cannot mean is that by
bearing children a woman gains salvation by her actions.
So we are reminded that “head” and “helper” are both difficult
jobs. Adam’s curse was that his word would be hard, and so the woman’s curse
was that there would be great pain in childbearing. Here is seems like there is
another struggle. One where men may have a difficult time doing the hard work
that is leading as the head, and taking responsibility over the actions of
their entire family. And women may have a hard time submitting to the role that
God has assigned them.
But also, continuing in faith, love and holiness, is a good
description of the life that each of us want to lead in Christ.
And pray together. To the One God. For everyone.
Reflecting:
I truly hope that this section of Scripture functions as a
good reminder of some things to do and to avoid, as it was to Timothy. But I
also recognize that when gender issues come up at all, there can be confusion
and hard feelings.
Please do not be afraid to ask any questions that you have
here, or explain any doubts or confusion that may accompany this topic for you.
To avoid it becoming a negative topic, I will also ask you
guys to answer this question:
What part of the role that God has assigned to your gender
are you thankful for? In what way are you thankful for the differences between
men and women?
Or, answer this:
What attitudes for worship that are listed here do you
especially want to cultivate?
There are actually a lot of topics opened up here. One thing that we do to show that worship is important and special is just simply setting the time aside ahead of time.
ReplyDeleteOur culture and our own selfish nature would want to leave worship on a sunday or wednesday as a maybe. "If I feel like it." But setting that time aside is one of the ways that the Holy Spirit moves us to respond to God's love for us.
What do you guys think about dressing in nice clothes? How can that be an act of worship? or isn't it?
Dressing up for church is a great thing. The idea of "dressed up" can vary from person to person but it is the thought that "I am going to a special event, I should look my best at this event." Though dressing up is not required at all, it is a good first step in showing appreciation for worship. Say you are going to a wedding and you wear a nice dress or suit because it is a special event and you want to look good. That is like worship/church! God blessed us with this wonderful opportunity to meet weekly and come together in fellowship and celebrate that we have life through His son. Nothing is better than that. So looking your "Sunday best" is a way of showing appreciation. And it doesn't always have to be on Sundays either, nowadays you can worship at a different congregation every day almost seven days a week!
ReplyDeleteAnother thing that i think we often lose sight of is the power and effectiveness of prayer. I think that we act like since God is so great, he wouldn't need us to pray. And in this section of Scripture, it is really clear that prayer is important.
ReplyDeleteIt causes me to think about what places in my life I can include it. a simple conversation between friends can include prayer, as well as I can ask my congregation to pray for something that is important in my life.
So a little of topic, but a general question...Where is the line between women giving devotion and leading in worship? Old Testament, Deborah the judge is leading Israel and putting guys to shame, but the NT it says women are not permitted to have authority over a man, Any clarification? #justwondering #thanksjoel
ReplyDeleteDeborah is a great example of someone following the concept here because she remained in her role as helper, but when the man, Balak, will not lead without here help, she helps him. She tells them that because there is no suitable man to do the job, and she is taking that role, God will shame him and honor a woman instead (Jael, the wife of Heber gets to be the one who delivers the Lord's justice and stars in the song of Deborah in Judges chapter 5).
ReplyDeleteI found this paragraph in an essay pretty clear:
"Paul's words, "I suffer not a woman to teach," are not to be taken absolutely. This is clear from the addition of the qualifying phrase, "Nor to usurp authority over the man." He does not exclude her from all teaching, but only from that which would involve exercising authority over men. Paul himself expressly instructs the aged women to be "teachers of good things," teaching "the young women to be sober, to love their husbands, to love their children, to be discreet, chaste, keepers at home, good, obedient to their own husbands, that the word of God be not blasphemed" (Tit. 2:3-5). A woman may, therefore, very properly conduct the devotions for a women's organization in the church. She may also teach a Bible class for women. But the prohibition that she is not to exercise authority over men clearly excludes her from becoming the pastor of a congregation. And for that reason, we do not ordain woman."
The truth is teaching Scripture to adult men, and making decisions for an entire congregation, or church body, are the areas where I see headship and authority. But the term "giving a devotion" and "leading in worship" are a bit more vague.
We might allow someone to sing a solo that teaches about Scripture, because the words have been approved by the head, and because that person has the gift and willingness to lead by singing. It wouldn't matter what gender they were in that case.
Could someone deliver a devotion that has been prepared ahead of time and approved without sinning? Yes, I think so. But we would avoid having a woman do that job if there was a man capable of and willing to delivering it.
I don't know if this is helpful. or if it raises more questions.